Note: Games in Gold Indicate Conference Contests; Bold Indicates Victor
| Date | Away | Score | Home | Score | |
| Nov. 14 | New Mexico Highlands | Cowboy Open | |||
| Nov. 22 | New Mexico Highlands | Northern Colorado Open | |||
| Dec. 3 | New Mexico Highlands | 12 | Colorado State-Pueblo | 34 | |
| Dec. 4 | New Mexico Highlands | Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational | |||
| Dec. 5 | New Mexico Highlands | Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational | |||
| Jan. 7 | New Mexico Highlands | 15 | Mesa State | 31 | |
| Jan. 8 | New Mexico Highlands | 15 | Adams State | 29 | |
| Jan. 15 | New Mexico Highlands | 49 | Texas A&M | 6 | |
| New Mexico Highlands | 21 | Newman | 24 | ||
| New Mexico Highlands | 9 | Central Oklahoma | 36 | ||
| Jan. 16 | New Mexico Highlands | 12 | Nebraska-Kearney | 33 | |
| Jan. 21 | Fort Hays State | 31 | New Mexico Highlands | 9 | |
| Jan. 22 | Central Oklahoma | 37 | New Mexico Highlands | 9 | |
| Feb. 5 | Grand Canyon | 37 | New Mexico Highlands | 9 | |
| Feb. 11 | Nebraska-Kearney | 34 | New Mexico Highlands | 9 | |
| Feb. 14 | New Mexico Highlands | 13 | Chadron State | 28 | |
| Feb. 17 | Western State | 37 | New Mexico Highlands | 6 | |
